JCB NXT 245HD LR VS Sany SY285C-9LR Excavator

desi-machines-jcb-excavator-nxt-245hd-lr-featured

JCB NXT 245HD LR

Weight

23850 Kg
Bucket

0.45 m³
Dig. Depth

12040 mm
Engine

Cummins 140 HP
Warranty

1 Yr. / 2000 hr.
Boom

8700 mm

₹ 81-83 Lakhs^*

Long Reach

desi-machines-sany-excavator-sy285c-9lr-featured

Sany SY285C-9LR

Weight

28610 Kg
Bucket

0.45 - 0.65 m³
Dig. Depth

14190 mm
Engine

Isuzu 173 HP
Warranty

1 Yr. / 2500 hr.
Boom

9800 mm

Price Available Soon^*

Long Reach

Add Equipment

The comparisons provided are based on the technical specifications published by the respective OEMs on their official websites and brochures. Please confirm these details directly with the OEMs before macking any final decision.

Key Highlights	JCB NXT 245HD LR	Sany SY285C-9LR

JCB NXT 245HD LR VS Sany SY285C-9LR Excavator

JCB NXT 245HD LR

₹ 81-83 Lakhs

Sany SY285C-9LR

Price Available Soon

Particulars	JCB NXT 245HD LR	Sany SY285C-9LR

Overview Summary

Comparing the JCB NXT 245HD LR and the Sany SY285C-9LR, both are long-reach excavators optimized for tasks such as dredging, mining, and waterfront constructions. The JCB model offers a balance of power and fuel efficiency with lower ground pressure, while the Sany model outshines with higher engine power and a more extended reach.

JCB NXT 245HD LR

Pros:

Equipped with a 140 HP Cummins engine offering balanced power and fuel efficiency.
Features a long reach of 15,620 mm, suitable for dredging and mining applications.
Boasts a reduced ground bearing pressure of 37.3 kPa for better stability.
Includes standard GPS and AC cabin for enhanced operator comfort and machine tracking.
Backed by a 1-year or 2000-hour warranty for reliability.

Cons:

Lower engine power compared to Sany SY285C-9LR, meaning potentially less performance in heavy-duty tasks.
Bucket capacity is fixed at 0.45 m³, providing fewer options for different job requirements.
Travel speed high is limited to 3.8 Km/h, possibly slower in operational movement compared to the Sany model.

Sany SY285C-9LR

Pros:

Higher engine power rated at 173 HP, offering superior performance for demanding tasks.
Extended reach of 17,770 mm, which is advantageous for deep excavations and waterfront construction.
Greater digging force at 88.4 kN, allowing for more efficient earthmoving capabilities.
Variable bucket capacity ranging from 0.45 - 0.65 m³, allowing for adaptability to different digging conditions.
Features a longer warranty period of 1-year or 2500 hours, providing additional assurance to the buyer.

Cons:

Higher ground bearing pressure at 48.1 kPa, potentially affecting maneuverability on softer grounds.
Operating weight is significantly higher, which might restrict access to certain work areas and increase the transportation cost.
Travel speed high is better at 5.5 Km/h but may translate to increased fuel consumption.

Closing Recommendation

Both excavators have their unique strengths and suitability will hinge on the job's requirements. For projects requiring higher power and extended reach capabilities, the Sany SY285C-9LR would be preferable. If ground pressure and warranty terms are the deciding factors, the JCB NXT 245HD LR may be more desirable. Ensure you consider warranty, operational costs, and job-specific requirements before making your decision.