Yanmar Vi020-6 VS Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U Excavator

desi-machines-yanmar-mini-excavator-vi020-6-featured

Yanmar Vi020-6

Weight

2185 Kg
Bucket

0.55 m³
Dig. Depth

2270 mm
Engine

Yanmar 20.1 HP
Warranty

1 Yr. / 2500 hr.
Boom

NA

₹ 25-26 Lakhs^*

Mini (0-6 Ton)

Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U

Weight

2356 Kg
Bucket

0.07 m³
Dig. Depth

2330 mm
Engine

Yanmar 17.4 HP
Warranty

1 Yr. / 2000 hr.
Boom

NA

₹ 23 - 24 Lakhs^*

Mini (0-6 Ton)

Add Equipment

The comparisons provided are based on the technical specifications published by the respective OEMs on their official websites and brochures. Please confirm these details directly with the OEMs before macking any final decision.

Key Highlights	Yanmar Vi020-6	Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U

Yanmar Vi020-6 VS Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U Excavator

Yanmar Vi020-6

₹ 25-26 Lakhs

Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U

₹ 23 - 24 Lakhs

Particulars	Yanmar Vi020-6	Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U

Overview Summary

The Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U and Yanmar Vi020-6 are both mini excavators designed for small-scale earthmoving and landscaping jobs. The ZAXIS 23U offers a strong digging force and a marginally larger operating weight, while the Vi020-6 has a higher power output and tech options such as an optional AC cabin and standard GPS.

Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U

Pros:

Equipped with a Yanmar 17.4 HP engine, suitable for small-scale earthmoving
Bucket digging force of 18.6 kN, good for tough soil conditions
Operating weight of 2356 Kg adds to its stability
Higher maximum digging reach on ground of 4060 mm
1-year or 2000-hour warranty which is industry standard
Features a gradeability of 25° (47%) for operating on slopes
Travel speeds are adequately high for such a compact excavator

Cons:

Smaller fuel tank capacity of 34 L compared to Yanmar Vi020-6
Does not offer an AC cabin, which may be a downside in hot climates
Maximum engine power slightly lower than Yanmar Vi020-6
Ground clearance of 290 mm could be limiting in uneven terrains

Yanmar Vi020-6

Pros:

Yanmar 20.1 HP engine is more capable in terms of raw power
GPS comes standard, making fleet management and security easier
AC cabin is optional, providing comfort in varied work environments
Relatively larger bucket capacity of 0.55 m³, may improve efficiency
25.1 L hydraulic tank capacity which is adequate for its operations
1-year or 2500-hour warranty providing slightly better coverage

Cons:

More expensive with a price range between ₹ 25-26 Lakhs
Slightly lesser travel speeds than ZAXIS 23U which may affect maneuverability
Lower ground bearing pressure of 26.7 kPa indicating lighter construction
Smaller fuel tank of 27.5 L might require more frequent refueling

Closing Recommendation

When choosing between these two models, consider the work environment and tasks at hand. If you're focusing on operator comfort and value-added features like GPS and plan to work in hotter climates, the Yanmar Vi020-6 may be more suitable. However, for slightly better performance in digging reach and stability, and if operating on slopes is important, the Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U could be the better option. Evaluate the pros and cons aligned to your specific needs and budget considerations.