JCB 55Z VS Kubota U50-5S Excavator

desi-machines-jcb-excavator-55z-featured

JCB 55Z

Weight

5520 Kg
Bucket

0.22 m³
Dig. Depth

3600 mm
Engine

Stage 47.8 HP
Warranty

1 Yr. / 2000 hr.
Boom

2866 mm

₹ 37-38 Lakhs^*

Mini (0-6 Ton)

desi-machines-kubota-excavator-u50-5s-featured

Kubota U50-5S

Weight

4780 Kg
Bucket

0.16 m³
Dig. Depth

3560 mm
Engine

Kubota 38.6 HP
Warranty

1 Yr. / 2500 hr.
Boom

NA

₹ 23-24 lakhs^*

Mini (0-6 Ton)

Add Equipment

The comparisons provided are based on the technical specifications published by the respective OEMs on their official websites and brochures. Please confirm these details directly with the OEMs before macking any final decision.

Key Highlights	JCB 55Z	Kubota U50-5S

JCB 55Z VS Kubota U50-5S Excavator

JCB 55Z

₹ 37-38 Lakhs

Kubota U50-5S

₹ 23-24 lakhs

Particulars	JCB 55Z	Kubota U50-5S

Overview Summary

The JCB 55Z and Kubota U50-5S are both robust mini excavators with distinct advantages. The JCB 55Z boasts more power and a larger bucket capacity, while the Kubota U50-5S is more affordable and includes a standard AC cabin. Users must weigh their specific needs such as power demand, budget constraints, and comfort requirements against each model's offerings.

JCB 55Z Mini Excavator

Pros:

Higher engine power with 47.8 HP contributing to more efficient operations
Larger bucket capacity at 0.22 m³ allows moving more material per scoop
Greater bucket digging force at 42 kN for better penetration and digging abilities
Longer maximum digging reach at 6200 mm provides extended operational range
More robust undercarriage length at 2490 mm, possibly allowing for better stability
Optional AC Cabin for operator comfort in extreme weather conditions

Cons:

Higher fuel consumption at 4 L/hour could result in increased operational costs
Potentially higher purchase price range of ₹ 37-38 Lakhs may impact budget considerations
Heavier operating weight, possibly affecting transport and movement on softer terrains

Kubota U50-5S Mini Excavator

Pros:

Standard AC Cabin included, enhancing operator comfort
Less expensive with a price range of ₹ 23-24 lakhs, offering a potentially better cost-efficiency
Higher gradeability at 30° can potentially handle steeper slopes easier
Slightly higher swing speed at 8.6 rpm, could offer marginal benefits in certain applications
Longer warranty period of 2500 hours, offering more confidence and potential savings on maintenance

Cons:

Lower engine power at 38.6 HP, which may affect the machine’s performance in tough conditions
Smaller bucket capacity of 0.16 m³, which could mean less material moved per cycle
Reduced bucket digging force at 36.5 kN may result in less effective digging in hard grounds
Less fuel-efficient with a mileage of 4.5 L/hour, potentially increasing running costs

Closing Recommendation

If operational performance and power take precedence and budget is less of a concern, the JCB 55Z might be the better option. On the other hand, for cost-sensitive projects where initial expenditure and operator comfort are key, the Kubota U50-5S would be a more suitable choice. Assess your project requirements and consider factors like warranty period, expected terrain, and the nature of tasks before finalizing the purchase.