Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U VS Sany SY27U Excavator

Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U

Weight

2356 Kg
Bucket

0.07 m³
Dig. Depth

2330 mm
Engine

Yanmar 17.4 HP
Warranty

1 Yr. / 2000 hr.
Boom

NA

₹ 23 - 24 Lakhs^*

Mini (0-6 Ton)

desi-machines-sany-mini-excavator-sy27u-featured

Sany SY27U

Weight

2680 Kg
Bucket

0.08 m³
Dig. Depth

2820 mm
Engine

Yanmar 20.4 HP
Warranty

1 Yr. / 2500 hr.
Boom

2100 mm

₹ 22.75-23.75 Lakhs^*

Mini (0-6 Ton)

Add Equipment

The comparisons provided are based on the technical specifications published by the respective OEMs on their official websites and brochures. Please confirm these details directly with the OEMs before macking any final decision.

Key Highlights	Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U	Sany SY27U

Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U VS Sany SY27U Excavator

Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U

₹ 23 - 24 Lakhs

Sany SY27U

₹ 22.75-23.75 Lakhs

Particulars	Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U	Sany SY27U

Overview Summary

The Sany SY27U and Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U are both mini excavators designed for small-scale operations. The Sany SY27U offers a more powerful engine, larger bucket capacity, and superior digging force, which are advantageous for tougher jobs. In contrast, the Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U has a smaller bucket, a less powerful engine but is lighter, potentially offering better maneuverability.

Sany SY27U Mini Excavator

Pros:

Higher engine power of 20.4 HP leading to potentially better performance
Larger bucket capacity of 0.08 m³ for more efficient digging and loading
Equipped with GPS as standard for better tracking and fleet management
Superior bucket digging force of 24.3 kN for tougher tasks
Longer warranty period of 1 Year / 2500 hours
Greater max digging depth of 2820 mm for deeper excavation
Higher gradeability of 30° for better performance on slopes

Cons:

Higher price range of ₹ 22.75-23.75 Lakhs compared to the competitor
Slightly larger operating weight which might affect transportability

Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U Mini Excavator

Pros:

Slightly lower price range of ₹ 23 - 24 Lakhs
Smaller and lighter, which may offer better maneuverability in tight spaces
Less fuel consumption with a smaller engine displacement of 1.115 L
Longer track length on the ground for potentially improved stability
Higher max torque which can be useful for operation

Cons:

Less powerful engine at 17.4 HP could mean reduced performance in certain tasks
Smaller bucket capacity of 0.07 m³ which may decrease efficiency
Shorter max digging reach and depth limiting the range of operation
Lower bucket digging force and arm digging force which might affect digging capability
Lacks GPS feature for fleet management or tracking
Shorter warranty period of 1 Year / 2000 hours

Closing Recommendation

If the decision is based on the capacity for more demanding digging tasks, the Sany SY27U seems to be the better choice considering its higher power and greater digging capabilities. However, if the work involves operating in confined spaces and a slight saving in cost is a factor, the Tata Hitachi ZAXIS 23U could be more suitable. Evaluate the specific requirements of the tasks at hand and choose the excavator that best fits the operational needs and budget constraints.