ACE F170 VS Escorts HYDRA 12 Crane

₹ 35 - 37 Lakh^*

ACE F170

Lift Capacity

17 Tonnes
Boom Height

21.6 m
Engine

Tata 74 HP
Weight

17040 kg
Turning Radius

7500 mm
Drive Type

2/4 Wheel drive

Pick & Carry Crane

₹ 16 - 18 Lakh^*

Escorts HYDRA 12

Lift Capacity

12 Tonnes
Boom Height

9.6 m, 11.3 m
Engine

E-Kubota 50 HP
Weight

10300 kg
Turning Radius

6300 mm
Drive Type

2 Wheel drive

Pick & Carry Crane

Add Equipment

The comparisons provided are based on the technical specifications published by the respective OEMs on their official websites and brochures. Please confirm these details directly with the OEMs before macking any final decision.

ACE F170 VS Escorts HYDRA 12 Crane

ACE F170

₹ 35 - 37 Lakh

Escorts HYDRA 12

₹ 16 - 18 Lakh

Particulars	ACE F170	Escorts HYDRA 12

Overview Summary

The ACE F170 and Escorts HYDRA 12 are Hydra cranes designed for different operational scales and conditions. The ACE F170 offers a superior lifting capacity, reach, and power but comes at a higher cost. In contrast, the Escorts HYDRA 12 is more budget-friendly, with good maneuverability and a much lighter operating weight, suitable for more frequent relocation and less intensive tasks.

ACE F170 Hydra Crane

Pros:

Impressive maximum lifting capacity of 17 tonnes suited for heavy-duty applications
Four-part telescoping boom extends to a significant height of 18.9 metres, with a maximum boom height of 21.6 m
Equipped with a more powerful engine generating 74 HP
Offers both 2-wheel and 4-wheel drive options for better versatility in different terrains
Higher maximum speed of 38 km/h without load for potentially faster transit times
40° articulation and a synchromesh transmission with 10 forward and 2 reverse speeds for improved movement and control
Hoist features a 4/6 falls configuration providing flexibility in lifting operations

Cons:

Higher price range of ₹ 35 - 37 Lakhs could be a downside for budget-conscious buyers
Heavier operating weight of 17,000 kg may contribute to more ground pressure and could restrict access to certain sites
Larger minimum turning radius of 7500 mm could be less desirable for very tight or confined spaces

Escorts HYDRA 12 Hydra Crane

Pros:

Cost-effective with a price range of ₹ 18 - 20 Lakhs, making it accessible for smaller budgets
Lighter operating weight of 8,850 kg, which can be beneficial for working on sensitive surfaces or where weight restrictions apply
Articulation of up to 50° and shorter minimum turning radius of 6250 mm provide excellent maneuverability in confined spaces
Designed with articulated power steering and a specially developed heavy-duty transmission for crane applications

Cons:

Lower maximum lifting capacity of 12 tonnes, which might limit its use in heavier lifts
The maximum boom height of 11 m may not be sufficient for operations that require higher reach
Less powerful engine with 49.5 HP may result in slower operations under load
Only 2-wheel drive, which could limit mobility in off-road or rugged terrain conditions
Lower maximum speed of 29 km/h without the load could result in slower transit times

Closing Recommendation

If the budget allows and tasks involve heavy lifting and higher reach, the ACE F170 is the suitable choice. However, for tighter spaces, lighter work, and cost savings, the Escorts HYDRA 12 is a sensible option. Consider the specific requirements of the job site and intended application before making a decision.