Escorts TRX 15 VS Indo Power 30FNX Crane

₹ 31 - 33 Lakh^*

Escorts TRX 15

Lift Capacity

15 Tonnes
Boom Height

21.0 m
Engine

Tata 75 HP
Weight

16645 kg
Turning Radius

7200 mm
Drive Type

4 Wheel Drive

Pick & Carry Crane

₹ 58 - 60 Lakh^*

Indo Power 30FNX

Lift Capacity

30 Tonnes
Boom Height

24.31 m
Engine

Indo Farm 137 HP
Weight

20060 kg
Turning Radius

10000 mm
Drive Type

2WD

Pick & Carry Crane

Add Equipment

The comparisons provided are based on the technical specifications published by the respective OEMs on their official websites and brochures. Please confirm these details directly with the OEMs before macking any final decision.

Escorts TRX 15 VS Indo Power 30FNX Crane

Escorts TRX 15

₹ 31 - 33 Lakh

Indo Power 30FNX

₹ 58 - 60 Lakh

Particulars	Escorts TRX 15	Indo Power 30FNX

Overview Summary

The Escorts TRX 15 is a capable machine designed for productivity in road works and general industry, with a significant 15-ton lifting capacity and agile maneuverability. On the other side, the Indo Power 30FNX is a robust contender with a larger lifting capacity of 30 tons and a more powerful engine, designed for demanding industrial applications.

Escorts TRX 15

Pros:

Has a 15-ton lifting capacity which is adequate for road works and general industrial movement.
Powered by a Turbocharged water cooled diesel engine of 75 HP for efficient operation.
Features a 4 Wheel Drive system for better traction and handling.
Equipped with a Synchromesh transmission gearbox offering 10 forward and 2 reverse speeds.
Boasts a maximum speed of 41 km/h without load, which is relatively high.
Offers a tight minimum turning radius of 7200 mm for better maneuverability in confined spaces.
4 parts telescoping boom, 3 parts hydraulically powered for better reach and stability.

Cons:

Lower maximum lifting capacity compared to Indo Power 30FNX.
Has a slightly less advanced steering system with Full power orbitrol compared to the articulated power steering of Indo Power 30FNX.
Boasts a smaller wheelbase which might affect stability in certain conditions.

Indo Power 30FNX

Pros:

High maximum lifting capacity of 30 tons for heavy-duty usage.
Engine offers a high power output of 137 HP, which can handle strenuous tasks efficiently.
Features a 2 Wheel Drive system which may be adequate for certain applications and offers cost savings in terms of fuel and maintenance.
Articulated power steering provides precise handling and is good for tough construction areas.
Safety features include fail-safe hoist brakes and counterbalance valves for improved operational safety.
Larger wheelbase of 5000 mm which may provide better stability.
The boom extends to 5 parts with semi-synchronous hydraulic operation for versatile reach.

Cons:

Higher operating weight could make it less efficient in fuel consumption and harder to transport.
Larger minimum turning radius of 10000 mm could pose challenges in tighter work spaces.

Closing Recommendation

The decision between the two should be based on the specific needs of the project. For lighter tasks and where maneuverability is key, the Escorts TRX 15 could be more suitable. However, for heavy-duty lifting and tasks requiring higher power, the Indo Power 30FNX stands out as the more capable machine, albeit with potential limitations in maneuverability and efficiency.