ACE NXP 150 VS Escorts HYDRA 14 Crane

₹ 41 - 43 Lakh^*

ACE NXP 150

Lift Capacity

15 Tonnes
Boom Height

21.0 m
Engine

Tata 49 HP
Weight

15310 kg
Turning Radius

6500 mm
Drive Type

4 Wheel Drive

Pick & Carry Crane

₹ 19 - 21 Lakh^*

Escorts HYDRA 14

Lift Capacity

14 Tonnes
Boom Height

15.1 m
Engine

E-Kubota 50 HP
Weight

11750 kg
Turning Radius

7000 mm
Drive Type

2 Wheel drive

Pick & Carry Crane

Add Equipment

The comparisons provided are based on the technical specifications published by the respective OEMs on their official websites and brochures. Please confirm these details directly with the OEMs before macking any final decision.

ACE NXP 150 VS Escorts HYDRA 14 Crane

ACE NXP 150

₹ 41 - 43 Lakh

Escorts HYDRA 14

₹ 19 - 21 Lakh

Particulars	ACE NXP 150	Escorts HYDRA 14

Overview Summary

The ACE NXP 150 and the Escorts HYDRA 14 are both competitive cranes suited for lifting and earthmoving tasks. The ACE NXP 150 stands out with its higher lifting capacity and 4-wheel drive, whereas the Escorts HYDRA 14 offers an environmentally friendly engine and lower operating weight.

ACE NXP 150

Pros:

Max. Lifting Capacity of 15 Tonnes which is slightly higher than its counterpart
Engine Type is water cooled which can typically require less maintenance and have a longer life
Transmission Type includes 8 forward and 2 reverse speeds with Hi-low drive selector for versatile speed control
4 Wheel Drive which provides better traction and control on varied terrains
Higher Max. Speed (Without Load) at 32 km/h enabling faster positioning
Has a 40° articulation which enhances maneuverability
Hoist is 4 falls; potentially providing more strength and stability in lifting operations
Max. Boom Height is 21.0 m, offering a higher reach in aerial access

Cons:

Operating Weight is higher at 15310 kg, which might restrict its operability on weak surfaces
Hoist Speed and other maintenance-related specifications like Engine Oil, Fuel Tank, etc., are not provided

Escorts HYDRA 14

Pros:

Higher Max. Power at 50 HP (37 kW) @ 2200 RPM which could mean better operational efficiency
Enums with a CEV Stage V engine which is usually more environmentally friendly
Creep Speed mentioned at 1.7 km/h, indicative of controlled slow movement for precision tasks
Has a slightly larger Fuel Tank (38 L), possibly leading to longer operation times without refueling
Two types of braking systems, enhancing safety measures
Hydraulic Pump is of Vane type, which could mean a more compact and quieter operation
Articulates up to 48°, providing good maneuverability
Lower Operating Weight of 11750 kg could be an advantage on sensitive grounds or when transporting the crane

Cons:

Max. Lifting Capacity is slightly less at 14 Tonnes
2 Wheel Drive which might limit movement in difficult terrain compared to a 4-wheel drive
Lower Max. Speed (Without Load) at 29 km/h
Max. Boom Height is lower at 15.1 m, which might restrict reach in some situations
Transmission type, while specialized for cranes, does not specify the technology used like synchromesh which aids in easier shifting

Closing Recommendation

For tasks requiring higher reach and better traction on various terrains, the ACE NXP 150 would be suitable. Conversely, for environmentally sensitive projects and areas where a lighter crane is beneficial, the Escorts HYDRA 14 might be the better choice.