JCB 2DX VS Tata Hitachi Shinrai Prime Backhoe Loader

₹ 18-20 Lakhs^*

JCB 2DX

Engine

KOEL 49 HP
Bucket

0.18 m³
Shovel

0.60 m³
Dig. Depth

3020 mm
Dump Height

2300 mm
Weight

5220 Kg

2WD

₹ 33-35 Lakhs^*

Tata Hitachi Shinrai Prime

Engine

Kubota 74.3 HP
Bucket

0.27 m³
Shovel

1.1 m³
Dig. Depth

4700 mm
Dump Height

2720 mm
Weight

8120 Kg

2WD/4WD

Add Equipment

The comparisons provided are based on the technical specifications published by the respective OEMs on their official websites and brochures. Please confirm these details directly with the OEMs before macking any final decision.

JCB 2DX VS Tata Hitachi Shinrai Prime Backhoe Loader

JCB 2DX

₹ 18-20 Lakhs

Tata Hitachi Shinrai Prime

₹ 33-35 Lakhs

Particulars	JCB 2DX	Tata Hitachi Shinrai Prime

Overview Summary

When comparing the JCB 2DX and Tata Hitachi Shinrai Prime CEV 5, the JCB 2DX offers greater maneuverability and is more suited for urban and confined spaces. On the other hand, the Tata Hitachi model provides greater power, digging depth, and capacity, designed for higher productivity in construction tasks.

JCB 2DX Backhoe Loader

Pros:

Compact and maneuverable machine ideal for urban construction and small sites
Equipped with a KOEL 4R810-NA 49 HP engine that delivers 203 Nm of torque
Hydraulic system features JCB Filtromatic Filter for efficient filtration
Boasts a good range of movement with a 182° bucket rotation angle
Lower machine weight of 5220 kg allows for easier transportation

Cons:

Lower gross power compared to Tata Hitachi Shinrai Prime at 49 HP
Smaller bucket and shovel capacity (0.18 m³ and 0.60 m³ respectively)
Max digging depth (3020 mm) less than Tata Hitachi Shinrai Prime
Lesser loader load over height than the Tata model at 2830 mm
Maximum pump flow and system pressure are lower than in the Tata Hitachi model

Tata Hitachi Shinrai Prime CEV 5 Backhoe Loader

Pros:

Equipped with a Kubota 74.3 HP engine with higher torque of 310 Nm
Larger bucket (0.27 m³) and shovel (1.1 m³) capacity for increased productivity
Higher digging depth capability at 4700 mm enhances working range
Features a superior pump flow of 113 L/min for efficient operations
Higher load over height at 3305 mm and stronger breakout forces for intensive tasks

Cons:

Heavier machine weight at 8120 kg could restrict mobility to some extent
A larger fuel tank (128 L) may imply a higher fuel carrying capacity and possibly increased operating weight
Requires more service fluids which could lead to higher service and maintenance costs
Maximum speed is slightly higher than JCB 2DX, which might not be a critical factor for backhoe operations
Overall length and height are greater, potentially making it less suitable for very confined spaces

Closing Recommendation

For tight working environments with less intensive work, the JCB 2DX may be the preferred choice due to its compact size and maneuverability. However, for projects requiring more power and larger scale operations, the Tata Hitachi Shinrai Prime CEV 5 would be the better option, given its enhanced specifications and capabilities.